Recently Sold — 1894 Rhettsbury Street, Carmel, IN 46032
FREE GUIDE FROM SHELDON
Thinking about what your home is worth?
Most people checking their own address are considering a move. Whether you're upsizing, downsizing, or just exploring — my free seller guide walks through pricing strategy, prepping for market, photography that sells, and what to expect at closing.
Get the seller guideIs this your home?
Sheldon Barnes can help you list 1894 Rhettsbury St
Sheldon Barnes is a Carmel realtor and licensed real estate agent serving Carmel, Indiana and the rest of Hamilton County. Whether you're ready to sell 1894 Rhettsbury St in The Village of Westclay or just curious what your home is worth in today's Carmel market, he can put together a no-pressure valuation.
ABOUT THIS HOME
A stunning reinvention of timeless European charm in the heart of the Village of WestClay, this 4 bedroom, 5 full bath and 2 half-bath home is where classic elegance meets everyday livability. Thoughtfully redesigned from top to bottom, every detail has been carefully selected by the current owners to blend historic character with fresh, modern style-creating a space that feels both luxurious and incredibly welcoming. Set across four spacious levels, this layout is perfect for multigenerational living, giving everyone their own sense of space and privacy while staying beautifully connected. Whether it's a guest suite, an in-law retreat, or a home office tucked away from the main living areas, each floor flows effortlessly-with the private elevator making it all incredibly accessible and convenient. The home's heart is filled with warmth and grace-from the elegant staircase and expansive owner's suite to the boutique-inspired closet and spa-like bath. Rich finishes and custom touches add style and personality throughout, while features like the climate-controlled wine cellar, sunny terraces, and peaceful pond views invite you to relax and enjoy. It's a home designed to be lived in, not just admired. A rare combination of craftsmanship, comfort, and thoughtful design-ideal for gathering, hosting, or simply savoring the beauty of everyday life.
$2,399,900
A stunning reinvention of timeless European charm in the heart of the Village of WestClay, this 4 bedroom, 5 full bath and 2 half-bath home is where classic elegance meets everyday livability. Thoughtfully redesigned from top to bottom, every detail has been carefully selected by the current owners ...
9,364
Sq Ft
2006
Year Built
0.2
Acres
Off Market
Status
$1,620,000
Assessed Value
4
Bedrooms
Key things to know
- Sold 6.2% below list in 34 days
- 3 fireplaces
- Finished basement (1,920 sqft)
- 3-car garage
- The Village of Westclay subdivision
Sold
$2,250,000
-$149,900 below list (-6.2%)
- Closed
- Apr 30, 2026
- Listed at
- $2,399,900
- Sold
- 3 weeks ago
- Sold in
- 34 days
Price history
- Sold$2,250,000
Apr 30, 2026
- Listedat $2,399,900
Feb 17, 2026
The Village of Westclay · activity
past 6 months
- Sold
- 45
- Median price
- $935,000
- Median DOM
- 8 days
Recent comparable sales

$2,579,900
1995 W 116th Street
5bd · 5ba · 5,574 sqft
Sold May 2026

$1,230,000
12621 Treaty Line Street
4bd · 5ba · 5,613 sqft
Sold May 2026

$1,610,000
1861 Blore Heath
5bd · 6ba · 6,446 sqft
Sold May 2026

$1,300,000
2746 Towne Meadow Drive
5bd · 5ba · 6,422 sqft
Sold May 2026

$1,450,000
1995 Telfair Street
5bd · 5ba · 5,568 sqft
Sold May 2026
Comparative value
5 comps in this range
This home is 55% above median for similar nearby sales.
Estimated values and comparable-sales ranges shown here are for informational purposes only. They are derived from public records and recent MLS sales, are not an appraisal or formal Comparative Market Analysis (CMA), and should not be used as the sole basis for any pricing, purchase, sale, or financing decision. For an accurate market value of a specific property, contact Sheldon Barnes for a personalized CMA.

Sheldon Barnes
Real Estate Agent · Carmel Realty LLC
License No. RB21000235
FEATURES & AMENITIES
Interior
Exterior
Climate
THE FACTS
Pricing trajectory, room-by-room layout, schools, and what's nearby.
Price history
$2,399,900Listed· Feb 17, 2026
34 days on market
Layout
Primary suite
Balcony,Closet Walk in
Primary bath
Suite,Tub Full with Separate Shower
Schools
Carmel Clay Schools
Neighborhood
- Carmel Central Park1.9 mi
- Zionsville Community HS3.0 mi
- Clay Terrace3.5 mi
- Carmel High School4.1 mi
- Carmel Arts & Design District4.1 mi
- Monon Trail (Carmel)4.2 mi
OFF-MARKET PROPERTY DETAILS
Living Area
9,364 sq ft
Year Built
2006
Stories
Three Or More
Lot Size
0.2 acres
Subdivision
Village of Westclay
Section 3001-A
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
5 full, 2 half
Garage
3 spaces
School District
Carmel Clay Schools
TAX ASSESSMENT
Hamilton County assessed values for current year
Total Assessed Value
$1,620,000
Land Value
$340,300
21% of total
Improvement Value
$1,279,700
79% of total
- Annual tax · 2024
- $15,552
- Exemption
- Homestead
PARCEL & LEGAL
Lot / Section
Section 3001-A
