HomeAboutServicesSearchAI ToursListingsMarket ActivityBlogContact
Sheldon Barnes, Carmel Realtor

Schedule a tour or ask a question

Sheldon Barnes can help you tour 3463 Plum Creek Road

Sheldon Barnes is a Carmel realtor and licensed real estate agent serving Nashville, Indiana and the rest of Hamilton County. Book a private tour of 3463 Plum Creek Road in Brown County, ask any question about this home, or talk through what you should know about buying in Nashville.

Follow

ABOUT THIS HOME

Rare investment opportunity in Nashville which has a 98% "Investability" rating on AirDNA! It offers immediate income potential, making it an exceptional addition to any investment portfolio. Nestled into what is arguably the most beautiful county in Indiana, sits this beautiful estate on 5.3 prime acres of wooded land with a private pond and views of the surrounding forests. The charm, warmth and character that only a finely crafted home can exude will become immediately apparent as you turn in to the drive. Custom built by a top-notch Craftsman you will be struck by unique design features, high quality finishes and floor plan. The exterior stone and fine wood craftmanship blends beautifully and seamlessly in the estate landscape. Yes, it's a custom home with impressive spaces but it's also a luxury rustic home that fits perfectly into the aura of Brown County. The entry level offers a grand great room with soaring ceilings, a Slate faced fireplace, massive views of your private pond and surrounding forests. Sliding doors to the large covered Lanai, the primary bedroom with En Suite, a 2nd bedroom plus a large less formal recreation room with a separate deck. The lower level offers a very large bunk room plus a lovely Guest Suite. The Coffee Bar/kitchenette and walk out to the pond will make this a favorite spot for family and guests. Enjoy Brown County State Park & Yellowwood State forests just outside your door. A fire pit and rustic outbuilding complete the backyard fun. The jaw dropping remodeled inside & outside will make you want to enjoy the outdoors whenever you can. This home is truly a magical combination of extraordinary quality and rustic beauty set on 5.3 acres of wooded land with a fishing pond. Home is ready for short term rental. Vacation home oasis.

Listed by Cathy O'Banion· United Real Estate Indpls· MLS# 22041957
SoldSold in 42 days

$775,000

$849,900

4Beds
3.1Baths
3,336Sq Ft

Rare investment opportunity in Nashville which has a 98% "Investability" rating on AirDNA! It offers immediate income potential, making it an exceptional addition to any investment portfolio. Nestled into what is arguably the most beautiful county in Indiana, sits this beautiful estate on 5.3 prime...

Listed by Cathy O'Banion· United Real Estate Indpls· MLS# MBR22041957

3,336

Sq Ft

1968

Year Built

4

Bedrooms

3.1

Bathrooms

Key things to know

  • Sold 13% below list in 42 days
  • Fireplace
  • Finished basement (1,308 sqft)
  • 5.3-acre lot
  • Brown County subdivision

Sold

$737,500

-$112,400 below list (-13.2%)

Closed
Aug 15, 2025
Listed at
$849,900
Sold
9 months ago
Sold in
42 days

Price history

  1. Sold$737,500

    Aug 15, 2025

  2. Price reduced$699,900 → $775,000

    Jul 7, 2025

  3. Listedat $849,900

    May 30, 2025

Sold
3
Median price
$230,000
Median DOM
32 days

Comparative value

5 comps in this range

This home is 43% above median for similar nearby sales.

$295K$681KMedian $515K
$738K

FEATURES & AMENITIES

Interior

Attic AccessBath Sinks Double MainCathedral Ceiling(s)Paddle FanHardwood FloorsWalk-In Closet(s)Vaulted Ceiling(s)

Exterior

BalconyLightingFire Pit

Climate

Heat: ZonedHeat: ElectricHeat: Forced AirHeat: DuctlessHeat: Heat PumpCool: Central AirCool: DuctlessCool: Heat Pump

THE FACTS

Pricing trajectory, room-by-room layout, schools, and what's nearby.

Price history

  • $849,900Listed· May 30, 2025

  • $775,000Reduced

    $74,900 (8.8% off original)

42 days on market

Layout

Main
22.15 rooms2,028 sq ft
Basement
214 rooms1,308 sq ft finished

Primary suite

Closet Walk in

Primary bath

Shower Stall Full,Suite

Schools

Brown County School Corporation

  • Elementary

    Helmsburg Elementary School

  • Middle

    Brown County Junior High

  • High

    Brown County High School

Neighborhood

  • Downtown Indianapolis37.1 mi
  • Zionsville Community HS49.8 mi
  • Monon Trail (Carmel)50.4 mi
  • Carmel Central Park50.5 mi
  • Carmel High School51.1 mi
  • IU Health North Hospital51.2 mi

PROPERTY DETAILS

Living Area

3,336 sq ft

Year Built

1968

Stories

One

Subdivision

Brown County

Bedrooms

4

Bathrooms

3 full, 1 half

School District

Brown County School Corporation

Powered by Ackee.ai