Sold — 3864 N Us HWY 231, Greencastle, IN 46135Schedule a tour or ask a question
Sheldon Barnes can help you tour 3864 N Us HWY 231
Sheldon Barnes is a Carmel realtor and licensed real estate agent serving Greencastle, Indiana and the rest of Hamilton County. Book a private tour of 3864 N Us HWY 231, ask any question about this home, or talk through what you should know about buying in Greencastle.
ABOUT THIS HOME
Take a look at this once in a lifetime property now up for sale. This stunning historic "O'Hair House" is now on the market after undergoing a complete renovation after a fire did great damage on it in Aug. 2019. It has now been restored to its full beauty and potential with all necessary updates for today's use. This SPRAWLING estate boasts almost 3500 sq feet in the main house, 6.56 acres to roam, a fully finished pole barn with bathroom and all utilities, AND a separate fully updated 1 bd 1 ba carriage house or in-law cottage. This property was originally constructed in 1879 and has it's stately historic character and mill-work preserved. The grand staircase in the foyer speaks for itself with one piece of charred wood intentionally left at the top to tell the story of the home, beautiful hardwood floors throughout and original doors inside and SOARING ceilings PLUS large bedrooms and windows for lots of natural light, exposed brick in various locations, wood-burning stove, WRAP AROUND PORCH with swing, enclosed mud room with back staircase off laundry, one bedroom on the main floor and 3 upstairs plus a loft space or potential for 5th bedroom. Enjoy the mature landscaping, large shade trees and "secret" garden behind the home. The possibilities here are great, this could be a wonderful "mini" farm or even a fantastic wedding venue! Perhaps just the perfect place for your own private retreat less than an hours drive from Indy to make use of all the amenities there, don't miss your chance to become part of the history of this estate.
$645,000
$675,000
Take a look at this once in a lifetime property now up for sale. This stunning historic "O'Hair House" is now on the market after undergoing a complete renovation after a fire did great damage on it in Aug. 2019. It has now been restored to its full beauty and potential with all necessary updates f...
3,428
Sq Ft
1879
Year Built
4
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
Key things to know
- Sold 11% below list in 95 days
- 2 fireplaces
- Basement
- 6.56-acre lot
Sold
$600,000
-$75,000 below list (-11.1%)
- Closed
- Sep 29, 2025
- Listed at
- $675,000
- Sold
- 7 months ago
- Sold in
- 95 days
Price history
- Sold$600,000
Sep 29, 2025
- Price reduced$675,000 → $645,000
Jun 17, 2025
- Listedat $675,000
Apr 10, 2025
Recent comparable sales

$285,000
1550 S Bloomington Street
3bd · 2ba · 2,982 sqft
Sold May 2026

$475,000
805 S County Road 300 W
4bd · 3ba · 3,788 sqft
Sold May 2026

$417,500
2012 Windemere Drive
3bd · 3ba · 2,928 sqft
Sold Apr 2026

$240,000
2057 S County Road 900 W
3bd · 2ba · 2,688 sqft
Sold Apr 2026

$345,000
462 Glenview Drive
3bd · 3ba · 3,222 sqft
Sold Mar 2026
Comparative value
5 comps in this range
This home is 74% above median for similar nearby sales.
FEATURES & AMENITIES
Interior
Exterior
Climate
THE FACTS
Pricing trajectory, room-by-room layout, schools, and what's nearby.
Price history
$675,000Listed· Apr 10, 2025
$645,000Reduced
↓ $30,000 (4.4% off original)
95 days on market
Layout
Schools
North Putnam Community Schools
Elementary
Bainbridge Elementary School
Middle
North Putnam Middle School
High
North Putnam Sr High School
Neighborhood
- Zionsville Community HS37.0 mi
- Downtown Indianapolis37.9 mi
- Carmel Central Park41.3 mi
- Monon Trail (Carmel)43.2 mi
- Clay Terrace43.3 mi
- Carmel High School43.5 mi
PROPERTY DETAILS
Living Area
3,428 sq ft
Year Built
1879
Stories
Two
Subdivision
No Subdivision
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
2 full
Garage
2 spaces
School District
North Putnam Community Schools

