HomeAboutServicesSearchAI ToursListingsMarket ActivityBlogContact
Sheldon Barnes, Carmel Realtor

Schedule a tour or ask a question

Sheldon Barnes can help you tour 5455 E High School Road

Sheldon Barnes is a Carmel realtor and licensed real estate agent serving Butlerville, Indiana and the rest of Hamilton County. Book a private tour of 5455 E High School Road, ask any question about this home, or talk through what you should know about buying in Butlerville.

Follow

ABOUT THIS HOME

The Historic John Hutton House | Circa 1860 Step back in time and discover The Historic John Hutton House, built circa 1860 for one of Butlerville's earliest and most prominent merchants. Rich in character and architectural charm, this impressive 2,636 square foot home sits on 2 beautiful acres and is ready for its next chapter. From the moment you enter, you're greeted by a stunning wraparound staircase that sets the tone for the craftsmanship and grandeur throughout. The main level offers expansive rooms that can be tailored to your vision - bedrooms, formal dining, library, parlor, living room, etc. A main-floor laundry room with hookups and a kitchen ready to be reimagined (or expanded) provide functional flexibility. Upstairs, you'll find three generously sized bedrooms and an additional full bath, offering space rarely found in homes of this era. Outside, the period-inspired wraparound porch invites you to slow down and enjoy peaceful country views - a perfect tribute to the home's 19th-century roots. Renovations have already begun, providing a strong foundation for restoration. Notable upgrades include: Upgraded HVAC system (2013) with supplemental upstairs mini-split Upgraded luxury windows throughout most of the home Luxury shutter blinds Drywall work in several rooms Newer high-end decorative shingle roof on most of the structure Durable composite siding on most of the exterior Three new exterior doors New electrical panels in both the home and detached garage The detached two-level garage offers incredible versatility, featuring interior water access and a sewer line - creating potential for future living quarters. With two 50-amp outlets and a sewer hookup, you could even connect a camper and live onsite while restoring this historic treasure. Whether you're an investor seeking opportunity or an owner-occupant with a vision to restore a timeless masterpiece, the possibilities here are truly endless. The John Hutton House

Listed by Andrew Flora· 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate· MLS# 22085315
Recently SoldSold in 4 days

$74,900

5Beds
2Baths
2,636Sq Ft

The Historic John Hutton House | Circa 1860 Step back in time and discover The Historic John Hutton House, built circa 1860 for one of Butlerville's earliest and most prominent merchants. Rich in character and architectural charm, this impressive 2,636 square foot home sits on 2 beautiful acres a...

Listed by Andrew Flora· 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate· MLS# MBR22085315

2,636

Sq Ft

1860

Year Built

5

Bedrooms

2

Bathrooms

Key things to know

  • Sold 0.1% over list in 4 days
  • 3 fireplaces
  • Basement
  • 2-acre lot

Sold

$75,000

+$100 over list (0.1%)

Closed
Apr 20, 2026
Listed at
$74,900
Sold
3 weeks ago
Sold in
4 days

Price history

  1. Sold$75,000

    Apr 20, 2026

  2. Listedat $74,900

    Feb 21, 2026

FEATURES & AMENITIES

Interior

Attic AccessEntrance FoyerHardwood FloorsHi-Speed Internet Availbl

Climate

Heat: Forced AirCool: Central Air

THE FACTS

Pricing trajectory, room-by-room layout, schools, and what's nearby.

Price history

  • $74,900Listed· Feb 21, 2026

4 days on market

Layout

Main
215 rooms1,478 sq ft
Upper
313 rooms1,158 sq ft

Schools

Jennings County School Corporation

  • Middle

    Jennings County Middle School

  • High

    Jennings County High School

Neighborhood

  • Downtown Indianapolis61.4 mi
  • Fishers High School69.7 mi
  • Conner Prairie69.8 mi
  • Hamilton Southeastern HS70.4 mi
  • Hamilton Town Center70.5 mi
  • IU Health North Hospital70.8 mi

PROPERTY DETAILS

Living Area

2,636 sq ft

Year Built

1860

Stories

Two

Subdivision

No Subdivision

Bedrooms

5

Bathrooms

2 full

Garage

1 spaces

School District

Jennings County School Corporation

Powered by Ackee.ai