Recently Sold — 5833 Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220
FREE GUIDE FROM SHELDON
Thinking about what your home is worth?
Most people checking their own address are considering a move. Whether you're upsizing, downsizing, or just exploring — my free seller guide walks through pricing strategy, prepping for market, photography that sells, and what to expect at closing.
Get the seller guideIs this your home?
Sheldon Barnes can help you list 5833 Winthrop Avenue
Sheldon Barnes is a Carmel realtor and licensed real estate agent serving Indianapolis, Indiana and the rest of Hamilton County. Whether you're ready to sell 5833 Winthrop Avenue in Forest Hills or just curious what your home is worth in today's Indianapolis market, he can put together a no-pressure valuation.
ABOUT THIS HOME
Welcome home to 5833 Winthrop Ave in the coveted Forest Hills neighborhood. This 4 bedroom 2 bathroom home has been lovingly updated over the years while maintaining the character of this esteemed neighborhood. The home is situated upon a hill with gorgeous landscaping leading you to the front entry and an inviting brick patio. Upon entry, you're greeted by original tile flooring in the entry and natural hardwood flooring throughout most of the main level. The living room features an arched built in bookshelf, gas fireplace and tons of natural light. The inviting dining room is prominent for family gatherings and located just off the galley kitchen. The wood paneled sitting room provides an additional area for friends and family. Off the dining room, the updated galley kitchen is well appointed with ample granite countertops and soft close drawers. There are three nicely sized bedrooms with natural hardwood floors and a cheeky full bathroom. Upstairs you will find an owner's paradise featuring a large loft area, bathroom with double sinks, glassed in shower and a dream of a closet. Don't miss the extra attic space off the closet! The basement is awaiting your vision for an additional living space. The outdoor space at this home is truly a dream! With a multiple sitting areas, you can enjoy your garden oasis for morning coffee and evening wine. With direct access to the Monon Trail via your own gate, you couldn't ask for more! This quiet neighborhood is walkable to a vibrant area full of restaurants, shopping, nightlife and more!
$625,000
Welcome home to 5833 Winthrop Ave in the coveted Forest Hills neighborhood. This 4 bedroom 2 bathroom home has been lovingly updated over the years while maintaining the character of this esteemed neighborhood. The home is situated upon a hill with gorgeous landscaping leading you to the front entry...
2,553
Sq Ft
1936
Year Built
Off Market
Status
4
Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
Key things to know
- Sold 4.0% over list in 2 days
- Fireplace
- Basement
- Forest Hills subdivision
Sold
$650,000
+$25,000 over list (4.0%)
- Closed
- Jun 2, 2026
- Listed at
- $625,000
- Sold
- 1 week ago
- Sold in
- 2 days
Price history
- Sold$650,000
Jun 2, 2026
- Listedat $625,000
May 1, 2026
Forest Hills · activity
past 6 months
- Sold
- 10
- Median price
- $662,000
- Median DOM
- 7 days
Recent comparable sales

$415,000
5639 Ralston Avenue
3bd · 2ba · 1,802 sqft
Sold Jun 2026

$395,000
6103 Indianola Avenue
3bd · 3ba · 1,920 sqft
Sold Jun 2026

$280,000
5769 Spruce Knoll Court
3bd · 3ba · 2,209 sqft
Sold Jun 2026

$323,500
2512 E 58th Street
3bd · 2ba · 2,250 sqft
Sold Jun 2026

$425,000
2750 Baur Drive
3bd · 2ba · 3,221 sqft
Sold Jun 2026
Comparative value
5 comps in this range
This home is 65% above median for similar nearby sales.
Estimated values and comparable-sales ranges shown here are for informational purposes only. They are derived from public records and recent MLS sales, are not an appraisal or formal Comparative Market Analysis (CMA), and should not be used as the sole basis for any pricing, purchase, sale, or financing decision. For an accurate market value of a specific property, contact Sheldon Barnes for a personalized CMA.
FEATURES & AMENITIES
Interior
Climate
THE FACTS
Pricing trajectory, room-by-room layout, schools, and what's nearby.
Price history
$625,000Listed· May 1, 2026
2 days on market
Layout
Primary suite
Closet Walk in
Primary bath
Sinks Double,Shower Stall Full
Schools
Indianapolis Public Schools
Neighborhood
- Downtown Indianapolis6.4 mi
- Monon Trail (Carmel)6.9 mi
- Carmel Central Park7.3 mi
- Carmel High School7.6 mi
- IU Health North Hospital7.9 mi
- Carmel Arts & Design District8.2 mi
OFF-MARKET PROPERTY DETAILS
Living Area
2,553 sq ft
Year Built
1936
Stories
One and One Half
Subdivision
Forest Hills
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
2 full
Garage
2 spaces
School District
Indianapolis Public Schools

