Sheldon Barnes
For Sale — 4231 Broadway Street, Indianapolis, IN 462054231 Broadway Street
Indianapolis, Indiana 46205
Hatherleigh
3
Beds
1
Baths
1,502
Sq Ft
1917
Year Built
0.12
Acres
Schedule a tour or ask a question
Sheldon Barnes can help you tour 4231 Broadway Street
Sheldon Barnes is a Carmel realtor and licensed real estate agent serving Indianapolis, Indiana and the rest of Hamilton County. Book a private tour of 4231 Broadway Street in Hatherleigh, ask any question about this home, or talk through what you should know about buying in Indianapolis.
ABOUT THIS HOME
This distinguished all brick residence, constructed in 1917, presents a unique opportunity for discerning individuals seeking a home with historical presence ripe for your personal touch. Encompassing 1502 square feet across two stories+ a full basement, this residence offers an expansive environment for comfortable daily routines and gracious hospitality with large central dining area and spacious kitchen with breakfast nook & back mudroom entry. The interior thoughtfully incorporates three private bedrooms, providing ample personal retreats for occupants, complemented by a full bathroom. The property extends its appeal outdoors with a substantial covered front porch on 5227 sq ft of lot area with full fenced back yard, presenting possibilities for cultivating an inviting exterior aesthetic or creating personalized outdoor sanctuaries. Single car garage provides store and auto space. This residence stands as a canvas for your personal touch & awaiting its next chapter. Newer HVAC system, new water heater, water softener & perfect location from city library, bus line and shops offers a great start point.
Key things to know
- All-brick exterior, 1917 construction
- Original hardwood floors throughout
- Full basement with expansion potential
- Covered front porch
- Fenced backyard
Browse by room
13 rooms · 34 photos
Monthly payment
Estimate · $254,900
$1,567/mo
≈ $1,357 principal & interest · $210 tax
Estimate only. Actual payment depends on lender, taxes, insurance, and HOA. Down payment $50,980 on a loan of $203,920.
Price history
- Price reduced$269,900 → $254,900
Mar 28, 2026
- Listedat $269,900
Mar 10, 2026
Hatherleigh · activity
past 6 months
- Sold
- 2
- Median price
- $1,599,500
- Median DOM
- 289 days
Recent comparable sales
$180,000
2436 Guilford Avenue
3bd · 1ba · 1,920 sqft
Sold May 2026
$215,000
4827 Brouse Avenue
2bd · 1ba · 1,075 sqft
Sold May 2026
$360,000
4822 Broadway Street
2bd · 1ba · 1,463 sqft
Sold May 2026
$133,000
4362 Evanston Avenue
3bd · 1ba · 1,193 sqft
Sold Apr 2026
$325,000
2450 Peoples Drive
3bd · 3ba · 1,526 sqft
Sold May 2026
Comparative value
5 comps in this range
This home is 19% above median for similar nearby sales.
Want to know anything specific? Ask about updates, finishes, the basement, the yard — I read the listing's photos, MLS data, and remarks and cite what I find.
FEATURES & AMENITIES
Interior
Climate
THE FACTS
Pricing trajectory, room-by-room layout, schools, and what's nearby.
Price history
$269,900Listed· Mar 10, 2026
$254,900Reduced
↓ $15,000 (5.6% off original)
38 days on market
Layout
Schools
Indianapolis Public Schools
Neighborhood
- Downtown Indianapolis4.5 mi
- Monon Trail (Carmel)8.8 mi
- Carmel Central Park9.2 mi
- Carmel High School9.4 mi
- IU Health North Hospital9.7 mi
- Carmel Arts & Design District10.1 mi
PROPERTY DETAILS
Combined data from the listing and Hamilton County records
Living Area
1,502 sq ft
Year Built
1917
Stories
Two
Subdivision
Hatherleigh
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
1 full
Garage
1 spaces
School District
Indianapolis Public Schools