HomeAboutServicesSearchListingsBlogContact
$849,0001940 Nantucket Drive
For Sale142 days on market

1940 Nantucket Drive

Cicero, Indiana 46034

Cicero Shores

$849,000

$895,000

Schedule a Showing

5

Beds

3

Baths

1,606

Sq Ft

1976

Year Built

0.38

Acres

Sheldon Barnes, Carmel Realtor

Schedule a tour or ask a question

Sheldon Barnes can help you tour 1940 Nantucket Drive

Sheldon Barnes is a Carmel realtor and licensed real estate agent serving Cicero, Indiana and the rest of Hamilton County. Book a private tour of 1940 Nantucket Drive in Cicero Shores, ask any question about this home, or talk through what you should know about buying in Cicero.

ABOUT THIS HOME

**HUGE PRICE DROP** Welcome to your completely reimagined lakefront retreat at 1940 Nantucket Drive on the main body of Morse Reservoir! This stunning 5-bedroom, 3-full-bath home has been meticulously updated from top to bottom and sits on an expansive .38-acre corner lot with direct lake access and breathtaking water views. Step outside to your private boat dock featuring a canopy & electric boat lift, seawall installed (2016) has been freshly sealed, double-decker lakeside patios including lakeside fire pit, and a huge back deck with new stone wall accent-perfect for entertaining or watching sunsets over the lake. Inside, you'll find a move-in-ready masterpiece with a gorgeous updated kitchen boasting quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, soft close cabinets, and barstool seating. Brand-new luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout, built for durability. Three completely remodeled modern bathrooms. Updated primary suite w/ high end tile shower. Fresh interior & exterior paint; updated lighting and sheik boho style light fixtures. HVAC system updated in 2022, roof in 2021, for year-round comfort. Storage shed under back deck and built in shelves in the garage. New front steps and front door. Every detail has been thoughtfully refreshed while preserving the timeless charm of this classic lake house. Located less than 20 minutes to Grand Park and just a short walk to the neighborhood park w/ new pickleball courts and a quick golf-cart ride to everything downtown Cicero has to offer-restaurants like Red Bridge Bistro, shops, and seasonal events. No HOA and plenty of room for boats, trailers, toys, or even a future pool, this rare turn-key lakefront property combines modern luxury with the laid-back lake lifestyle you've been dreaming of. Big in all the right places: lakeside entertainment space, yard size & bed/bath count to enjoy w/ friends. Investors - Amazing AirBnB opportunity w/ $100k+ projected booking revenue!

Listed by Zachary Canull· Canull Group LLC· MLS# 22075705

Ask about this home

QUESTIONS ABOUT 1940 NANTUCKET DRIVE?

Ask anything — the AI reads the listing's full data, photo features, and MLS remarks. Cites the source so you can verify.

Try

5 questions left

AI-curated highlights

INSIDE THIS HOME

FEATURES & AMENITIES

Interior

Attic AccessKitchen IslandEat-in KitchenWood Work Painted

Exterior

Fire PitStorage Shed

Climate

Heat: Natural GasHeat: High Efficiency (90%+ AFUE )Cool: Central Air

AI-detected from photos

Vibe:contemporaryupdated

THE FACTS

Pricing trajectory, room-by-room layout, schools, and what's nearby.

Price history

  • $895,000Listed· Dec 3, 2025

  • $849,000Reduced

    $46,000 (5.1% off original)

142 days on market

Layout

Main
213 rooms480 sq ft
Upper
326 rooms1,126 sq ft

Primary bath

Suite

Schools

Hamilton Heights School Corp

  • Elementary

    Hamilton Heights Elementary School

  • Middle

    Hamilton Heights Middle School

  • High

    Hamilton Heights High School

Neighborhood

  • Westfield High School7.3 mi
  • Hamilton Town Center9.2 mi
  • Hamilton Southeastern HS9.3 mi
  • Conner Prairie10.3 mi
  • Clay Terrace10.4 mi
  • Fishers High School10.5 mi

PROPERTY DETAILS

Combined data from the listing and Hamilton County records

Living Area

1,606 sq ft

Year Built

1976

Subdivision

Cicero Shores

Bedrooms

5

Bathrooms

3 full

Garage

2 spaces

School District

Hamilton Heights School Corp

AI deal analysis

HOW THIS HOME COMPARES

AI synthesis across 6 similar listings — pricing, distinctive features, era, and honest risk flags.

Scroll to load…