Sheldon Barnes
For Sale — 2009 Plum Street, New Castle, IN 473622009 Plum Street
New Castle, Indiana 47362
No Subdivision
$179,000
Schedule a Showing4
Beds
1
Baths
1,414
Sq Ft
1900
Year Built
0.16
Acres
Schedule a tour or ask a question
Sheldon Barnes can help you tour 2009 Plum Street
Sheldon Barnes is a Carmel realtor and licensed real estate agent serving New Castle, Indiana and the rest of Hamilton County. Book a private tour of 2009 Plum Street, ask any question about this home, or talk through what you should know about buying in New Castle.
ABOUT THIS HOME
4BR/1BA home. Step in from the covered front porch. Main-level has Living room, Eat-in kitchen w/Breakfast bar, BR's 2, 3 & 4 & full bath. Upper level can be used as Master bedroom. Unfinished basement w/laundry area. Partially covered deck in the relaxing fenced and shaded backyard. HVAC brand new. Roof 10 yrs old. 2-car detached garage with shop area. Close to downtown. Move in and call it home!
Key things to know
- Covered front porch
- 4 bedrooms, 1 bath
- New HVAC system
- Fenced and shaded backyard with deck
- Detached 2-car garage with shop area
Monthly payment
Estimate · $179,000
$1,040/mo
≈ $953 principal & interest · $88 tax
Estimate only. Actual payment depends on lender, taxes, insurance, and HOA. Down payment $35,800 on a loan of $143,200.
Price history
- Listedat $179,000
Apr 24, 2026
Recent comparable sales
$140,000
1324 S 21st Street
3bd · 1ba · 1,092 sqft
Sold May 2026
$348,700
1745 W County Road 200 North
3bd · 2ba · 1,808 sqft
Sold Apr 2026
$165,000
404 N 20th Street
3bd · 2ba · 1,125 sqft
Sold Apr 2026
$230,000
729 I Avenue
3bd · 2ba · 1,568 sqft
Sold Apr 2026
$225,000
501 S Hardacre Court
3bd · 2ba · 1,424 sqft
Sold Apr 2026
Comparative value
5 comps in this range
This home is 20% below median for similar nearby sales.
Want to know anything specific? Ask about updates, finishes, the basement, the yard — I read the listing's photos, MLS data, and remarks and cite what I find.
FEATURES & AMENITIES
Interior
Climate
THE FACTS
Pricing trajectory, room-by-room layout, schools, and what's nearby.
Price history
$179,000Listed· Apr 24, 2026
4 days on market
Layout
Schools
New Castle Community School Corp
Middle
New Castle Middle School
Neighborhood
- Hamilton Town Center32.1 mi
- Hamilton Southeastern HS32.8 mi
- Conner Prairie34.3 mi
- Fishers High School34.4 mi
- IU Health North Hospital37.7 mi
- Monon Trail (Carmel)40.2 mi
PROPERTY DETAILS
Combined data from the listing and Hamilton County records
Living Area
1,414 sq ft
Year Built
1900
Stories
Two
Subdivision
No Subdivision
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
1 full
Garage
2 spaces
School District
New Castle Community School Corp