Homes Under $500k for Sale in New Castle, IN
45 active homes under $500k for sale in New Castle, Indiana — median price $139,900, ranging from $15,000 to $472,500. Updated continuously from the MLS.
Listings
$15,000For Sale1015 S 24th Street
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 784 1900
$29,000For Sale3024 C Avenue
New Castle, IN 47362
4 1 1,728 1938
$57,900For Sale1222 Webster Avenue
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 1,388 1925
$62,271For Sale1819 S Main Street
New Castle, IN 47362
3 1 1,178 1900
$64,999For Sale1621 R Avenue
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 770 1945
$70,000For Sale1718 Irvin Street
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 1,192 1900- $73,900For Sale
1421 S 23rd Street
New Castle, IN 47362
3 1 744 1911 
$79,799For Sale422 S 18th Street
New Castle, IN 47362
5 2 1,744 1900
$82,499For Sale1324 J Avenue
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 1,320 1900
$84,900For Sale2820 Brown Street
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 1,447 1900
$85,000For Sale3935 E Brown Road
New Castle, IN 47362
4 2 2,208 1900
$94,900For Sale2301 S 19th Street
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 660 1955
$101,000For Sale315 S 25th Street
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 880 1937
$104,499For Sale1324 Thornburg Street
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 1,400 1900
$105,000For Sale224 Reddingdale Drive
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 902 1900
$109,900For Sale2029 Lincoln Avenue
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 792 1928
$116,500For SaleOpen · Wed 8 AM–10 PM803 S 22nd Street
New Castle, IN 47362
1 1 694 1925
$129,000For Sale3015 S Main Street
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 1,011 1958
$129,900For Sale1122 S 21st Street
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 1,152 1918
$129,995For Sale2406 Broad Street
New Castle, IN 47362
3 2 1,450 1920
$130,000For Sale1913 E County Road 400 S
New Castle, IN 47362
3 2 2,664 2004
$134,900For Sale431 N 14th Street
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 816 1952
$139,900For Sale2234 Walnut Street
New Castle, IN 47362
3 1 2,520 1900
$139,900For Sale2912 Outer Drive
New Castle, IN 47362
3 1 1,119 1961
$145,000For Sale5362 S Old State Road 103
New Castle, IN 47362
4 2 1,568 1967
$147,500For Sale2818 D Avenue
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 898 2025
$149,000For Sale1223 S 21st Street
New Castle, IN 47362
3 3 1,956 1975
$149,900For Sale1211 S 17th Street
New Castle, IN 47362
2 2 1,519 1900
$152,000For Sale644 S 11th Street
New Castle, IN 47362
3 2 1,512 1950
$160,000For Sale1404 S 23rd Street
New Castle, IN 47362
3 2 1,130 1945
$169,900For Sale119 S 18th Street
New Castle, IN 47362
4 2 2,272 1950
$179,000For Sale2009 Plum Street
New Castle, IN 47362
4 1 1,414 1900
$185,000For Sale1617 Plymouth Drive
New Castle, IN 47362
3 1 1,372 1969
$219,900For Sale520 Hawthorn Road
New Castle, IN 47362
3 2 1,776 1950
$239,900For Sale921 N 14th Street
New Castle, IN 47362
4 1 2,460 1900
$265,900For SaleOpen · Sun 5 PM–7 PM5131 E County Road 300 S
New Castle, IN 47362
4 1 2,166 1900
$289,000For Sale930 Jameson Court
New Castle, IN 47362
4 2 2,636 1963
$320,000For Sale950 Jameson Court
New Castle, IN 47362
3 3 1,721 1964
$329,000For SaleOpen · Sun 5 PM–7 PM1128 W County Road 300 N
New Castle, IN 47362
2 1 1,300 1976
$344,400For SaleOpen · Thu 9 PM–11 PM402 Luellen Way
New Castle, IN 47362
3 2 1,469 2025
$349,000For Sale80 S Greensboro Pike
New Castle, IN 47362
3 2 1,377 2006
$365,000For Sale1334 S Onyx Court
New Castle, IN 47362
3 2 2,192 1982
$369,900For Sale2702 Meadowbrook Drive
New Castle, IN 47362
3 2 3,568 1963
$429,000For Sale3806 S State Road 3
New Castle, IN 47362
3 2 2,688 1936
$472,500For Sale4517 E County Road 400 S
New Castle, IN 47362
4 2 1,984 1965