Homes Under $500k for Sale in New Palestine, IN
27 active homes under $500k for sale in New Palestine, Indiana — median price $388,900, ranging from $225,000 to $489,900. Updated continuously from the MLS.
Listings
$225,000For Sale4992 W 100 S
New Palestine, IN 46163
3 1 1,420 1900
$318,000For Sale2071 S 600 W
New Palestine, IN 46163
3 3 2,013 1952
$340,000For Sale7838 W US Highway 52
New Palestine, IN 46163
3 2 1,670 1961
$349,900For Sale4739 W Harrisburg Court
New Palestine, IN 46163
3 2 2,211 2006
$350,000For Sale4985 W Burrel Lane
New Palestine, IN 46163
5 3 2,580 2021
$359,900For Sale4506 W Easy Street
New Palestine, IN 46163
4 3 2,722 2004
$364,900For Sale5026 W Stonehaven Lane
New Palestine, IN 46163
3 3 2,033 2015
$364,900For Sale5179 W Blue Bell Drive
New Palestine, IN 46163
3 2 2,554 1976
$364,995For Sale4702 Black Willow Way
New Palestine, IN 46163
3 2 1,801 2026
$365,000For SaleOpen · Sun 5 PM–7 PM2306 S Bingham Place
New Palestine, IN 46163
5 3 2,419 2022
$370,000For Sale2321 S Bingham Place
New Palestine, IN 46163
5 3 2,760 2021
$375,000For Sale2503 S Carlota Drive
New Palestine, IN 46163
5 3 2,760 2023
$379,000For Sale983 S Raylee Garden Drive
New Palestine, IN 46163
4 3 2,722 2018
$388,900For Sale7950 Dogwood Court
New Palestine, IN 46163
5 3 2,600 2025- $399,900For Sale
7961 Magnolia Street
New Palestine, IN 46163
5 3 2,600 2025 
$404,695For Sale7808 Magnolia Street
New Palestine, IN 46163
4 3 1,961 2026
$414,900For Sale7760 Magnolia Street
New Palestine, IN 46163
4 3 2,278 2025
$415,000For Sale2475 S Copperstone Drive
New Palestine, IN 46163
4 3 2,859 2021
$419,900For Sale1343 S Buttercup Drive
New Palestine, IN 46163
5 4 2,465 1976
$420,000For Sale1281 Fox Trail Drive E
New Palestine, IN 46163
3 2 2,396 1979
$425,000For Sale3801 S Cedar Creek Lane
New Palestine, IN 46163
4 3 2,186 2003
$429,995For Sale3860 White Willow Way
New Palestine, IN 46163
5 4 2,782 2026
$440,000For Sale4677 W Harvest Way
New Palestine, IN 46163
5 4 3,751 2004
$450,000For Sale3862 W 400 S
New Palestine, IN 46163
3 2 1,539 1965
$468,830For Sale7781 Magnolia Street
New Palestine, IN 46163
5 4 3,388 2026
$480,000For Sale2391 S Stonehill Way
New Palestine, IN 46163
5 5 3,504 2021
$489,900For SaleOpen · Sat 5 PM–7 PM4724 White Willow Way
New Palestine, IN 46163
4 3 2,654 2025