Homes Under $500k for Sale in Spencer, IN
23 active homes under $500k for sale in Spencer, Indiana — median price $375,000, ranging from $139,900 to $449,900. Updated continuously from the MLS.
Listings
$139,900For Sale206 N East Street
Spencer, IN 47460
2 1 1,184 1920
$159,000For Sale3605 State Highway 43
Spencer, IN 47460
1 1 849 2021
$195,000For Sale501 W Jefferson Street
Spencer, IN 47460
3 1 1,000 1950
$225,000For Sale2603 S Cataract Road
Spencer, IN 47460
3 2 1,344 1999
$229,000For Sale1892 Maze Road
Spencer, IN 47460
3 1 1,120 1968
$229,900For Sale767 Laymon Avenue
Spencer, IN 47460
4 1 1,360 1950
$237,500For Sale456 W Hillside Avenue
Spencer, IN 47460
4 2 2,704 1904
$299,000For Sale313 Concord Road
Spencer, IN 47460
3 2 1,274 1989
$319,900For Sale4304 Newport Drive
Spencer, IN 47460
3 1 2,408 1977
$330,000For Sale2930 Withem Avenue
Spencer, IN 47460
4 3 2,204 2019
$374,900For Sale45 Flatwoods Road
Spencer, IN 47460
4 3 3,502 1986
$375,000For Sale9677 W Reeves Road
Spencer, IN 47460
4 2 2,688 1985
$375,000For Sale110 Pin Oak Road
Spencer, IN 47460
3 3 1,847 2025
$385,000For Sale1446 W State Highway 46
Spencer, IN 47460
5 3 3,321 1940
$399,000For Sale710 White Oak Road
Spencer, IN 47460
3 2 2,220 2025
$399,000For Sale534 E Dogwood Court
Spencer, IN 47460
3 3 2,051 2025
$399,000For Sale712 White Oak Road
Spencer, IN 47460
3 2 2,127 2025
$399,900For Sale681 Hancock School Road
Spencer, IN 47460
2 2 2,130 1955
$400,000For Sale106 Pin Oak Road
Spencer, IN 47460
4 2 1,947 2025
$409,900For Sale982 E Coonpath Road
Spencer, IN 47460
3 2 1,739 1974
$415,000For Sale7373 Locust Lake Road
Spencer, IN 47460
4 3 2,350 1998
$439,900For Sale1320 Red Cedar Lane
Spencer, IN 47460
6 3 3,780 1999
$449,900For Sale981 Denali Drive
Spencer, IN 47460
6 3 3,051 2005